Scouting Requirements: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
==Scouting Questions and Useful Data Points== | ==Scouting Questions and Useful Data Points== | ||
=== '''Auto''' === | ==='''Auto'''=== | ||
* From which part of the field did they score? ... refer to pre-determined imaginary zones | *From which part of the field did they score? ... refer to pre-determined imaginary zones | ||
* Do they need to start in specific spot(s). ... flexibility for starting position | *Do they need to start in specific spot(s). ... flexibility for starting position | ||
* How many power cells did they pick up? | *How many power cells did they pick up? | ||
* Other. What else did the do or not do?... text field | *Other. What else did the do or not do?... text field | ||
Data most likely available from Blue Alliance | Data most likely available from Blue Alliance | ||
* How many points did they score? | *How many points did they score? | ||
* Did they cross the line? | *Did they cross the line? | ||
* How many points from each power port? | *How many points from each power port? | ||
=== '''Teleop''' === | ==='''Teleop'''=== | ||
==== Scoring ==== | ====Scoring==== | ||
* From which part of the field did/can they score and into which power port? ... refer to pre-determined imaginary zones | *From which part of the field did/can they score and into which power port? ... refer to pre-determined imaginary zones | ||
* Can they score in each power port (BA data will have points, this may be more of an ability question) | *Can they score in each power port (BA data will have points, this may be more of an ability question) | ||
* Scoring cycle time? ... time to line up and shoot x power cells (coupled with intake cycle time should reflect a strong scorer) | *Scoring cycle time? ... time to line up and shoot x power cells (coupled with intake cycle time should reflect a strong scorer) | ||
* Shooting accuracy. .... shots vs. misses ... per power port | *Shooting accuracy. .... shots vs. misses ... per power port | ||
* Can they score quickly into any power port to complete a stage? | *Can they score quickly into any power port to complete a stage? | ||
* Other ... text field | *Other ... text field | ||
==== Intake and Ball Control ==== | ====Intake and Ball Control==== | ||
* How many power cells did they pick up? ... ball control ... assert pressure on other team | *How many power cells did they pick up? ... ball control ... assert pressure on other team | ||
* How many power cells can they control? | *How many power cells can they control? | ||
* From which field areas are they able to intake the power cell? loading bay, ground, rebound, trench run, energizer | *From which field areas are they able to intake the power cell? loading bay, ground, rebound, trench run, energizer | ||
* Intake cycle time? ... time to intake x power cells | *Intake cycle time? ... time to intake x power cells | ||
==== Control Panel ==== | ====Control Panel==== | ||
* Did they try to operate the control panel? | *Did they try to operate the control panel? | ||
* Were they successful at rotation? | *Were they successful at rotation? | ||
* Were they successful at position? | *Were they successful at position? | ||
==== Hang ==== | ====Hang==== | ||
* Can they lift and hang? | *Can they lift and hang? | ||
* Section of the bar where they hung. .. center, mid, end, (anywhere) | *Section of the bar where they hung. .. center, mid, end, (anywhere) | ||
* At what height can they lift and hang? | *At what height can they lift and hang? | ||
* Lift / hang cycle time? | *Lift / hang cycle time? | ||
* DId they hang first or second? | *DId they hang first or second? | ||
* Did they assist another team? | *Did they assist another team? | ||
* Do they obstruct other robots? | *Do they obstruct other robots? | ||
* Can they level individually? | *Can they level individually? | ||
* Can they assist leveling even if from the ground? | *Can they assist leveling even if from the ground? | ||
==== Team Play ==== | ====Team Play==== | ||
* Can they pass? | *Can they pass? | ||
* Can they receive a pass? | *Can they receive a pass? | ||
* Defensive capability - apply pressure on opposing alliance | *Defensive capability - apply pressure on opposing alliance | ||
* Speed ... may be a general rating | *Speed ... may be a general rating | ||
* Do they break down? Which specific components or abilities were impacted? | *Do they break down? Which specific components or abilities were impacted? | ||
* Fouls...Did they foul and where ... discipline | *Fouls...Did they foul and where ... discipline | ||
* Did they play defense? .... or any other match play that would impact other factors like scoring. | *Did they play defense? .... or any other match play that would impact other factors like scoring. | ||
* Other Special skills | *Other Special skills | ||
* How easy are they to work with? ... objective note | *How easy are they to work with? ... objective note | ||
* Notes | *Notes | ||
==== Complementary Skills ==== | ====Complementary Skills==== | ||
* Can they trench run? ... if they can't they will be competing for space on the field with us. Also they would have better ability to control power cells in the trench. | *Can they trench run? ... if they can't they will be competing for space on the field with us. Also they would have better ability to control power cells in the trench. | ||
* In Auto, do they limit our starting position or actions? | *In Auto, do they limit our starting position or actions? | ||
* Other complementary skills | *Other complementary skills | ||
* (limiting factor is our tall robot. If we package in short form we'll remove this list item, but this list should ideally grow as we identify capabilities that would be beneficial or detrimental to us. A good example may be control panel if we are not able to execute that, or leveling) | *(limiting factor is our tall robot. If we package in short form we'll remove this list item, but this list should ideally grow as we identify capabilities that would be beneficial or detrimental to us. A good example may be control panel if we are not able to execute that, or leveling) | ||
==== Scouting data in pits, not from matches ==== | ====Scouting data in pits, not from matches==== | ||
* Notes | *Notes | ||
<br /> | <br /> | ||
Line 79: | Line 79: | ||
Based on last year, the following should be available from the Blue Alliance API | Based on last year, the following should be available from the Blue Alliance API | ||
* Scoring in upper lower and rear | *Scoring in upper lower and rear | ||
* Total auto points ...Auto.. cross line, score? | *Total auto points ...Auto.. cross line, score? | ||
* Total stage points? | *Total stage points? | ||
* Ranking Points for team ... ie total | *Ranking Points for team ... ie total | ||
* Climb points | *Climb points | ||
* OPR, DPR, CCWM: Offensive/Defensive Power Ranking, Calculated Contribution to Winning Margin. <nowiki>http://www.cornerstonerobotics.net/power-rankings.html</nowiki>. BPR app <nowiki>https://www.reddit.com/r/FRC/comments/7hrtnr/breakdown_power_rating_bpr_a_new_power_metric/?utm_source=amp&utm_medium=&utm_content=post_body</nowiki> | *OPR, DPR, CCWM: Offensive/Defensive Power Ranking, Calculated Contribution to Winning Margin. <nowiki>http://www.cornerstonerobotics.net/power-rankings.html</nowiki>. BPR app <nowiki>https://www.reddit.com/r/FRC/comments/7hrtnr/breakdown_power_rating_bpr_a_new_power_metric/?utm_source=amp&utm_medium=&utm_content=post_body</nowiki> | ||
==Analytics== | ==Analytics== | ||
Line 94: | Line 94: | ||
==Sites and Apps== | ==Sites and Apps== | ||
• FRC Tracker <nowiki>https://frctracker.com/</nowiki> | • FRC Tracker <nowiki>https://frctracker.com/</nowiki> | ||
more here ... review and note the good and the bad --> [[Scouting Notes]] |
Revision as of 10:55, 15 January 2020
Scouting Questions and Useful Data Points
Auto
- From which part of the field did they score? ... refer to pre-determined imaginary zones
- Do they need to start in specific spot(s). ... flexibility for starting position
- How many power cells did they pick up?
- Other. What else did the do or not do?... text field
Data most likely available from Blue Alliance
- How many points did they score?
- Did they cross the line?
- How many points from each power port?
Teleop
Scoring
- From which part of the field did/can they score and into which power port? ... refer to pre-determined imaginary zones
- Can they score in each power port (BA data will have points, this may be more of an ability question)
- Scoring cycle time? ... time to line up and shoot x power cells (coupled with intake cycle time should reflect a strong scorer)
- Shooting accuracy. .... shots vs. misses ... per power port
- Can they score quickly into any power port to complete a stage?
- Other ... text field
Intake and Ball Control
- How many power cells did they pick up? ... ball control ... assert pressure on other team
- How many power cells can they control?
- From which field areas are they able to intake the power cell? loading bay, ground, rebound, trench run, energizer
- Intake cycle time? ... time to intake x power cells
Control Panel
- Did they try to operate the control panel?
- Were they successful at rotation?
- Were they successful at position?
Hang
- Can they lift and hang?
- Section of the bar where they hung. .. center, mid, end, (anywhere)
- At what height can they lift and hang?
- Lift / hang cycle time?
- DId they hang first or second?
- Did they assist another team?
- Do they obstruct other robots?
- Can they level individually?
- Can they assist leveling even if from the ground?
Team Play
- Can they pass?
- Can they receive a pass?
- Defensive capability - apply pressure on opposing alliance
- Speed ... may be a general rating
- Do they break down? Which specific components or abilities were impacted?
- Fouls...Did they foul and where ... discipline
- Did they play defense? .... or any other match play that would impact other factors like scoring.
- Other Special skills
- How easy are they to work with? ... objective note
- Notes
Complementary Skills
- Can they trench run? ... if they can't they will be competing for space on the field with us. Also they would have better ability to control power cells in the trench.
- In Auto, do they limit our starting position or actions?
- Other complementary skills
- (limiting factor is our tall robot. If we package in short form we'll remove this list item, but this list should ideally grow as we identify capabilities that would be beneficial or detrimental to us. A good example may be control panel if we are not able to execute that, or leveling)
Scouting data in pits, not from matches
- Notes
Blue Alliance Data
Based on last year, the following should be available from the Blue Alliance API
- Scoring in upper lower and rear
- Total auto points ...Auto.. cross line, score?
- Total stage points?
- Ranking Points for team ... ie total
- Climb points
- OPR, DPR, CCWM: Offensive/Defensive Power Ranking, Calculated Contribution to Winning Margin. http://www.cornerstonerobotics.net/power-rankings.html. BPR app https://www.reddit.com/r/FRC/comments/7hrtnr/breakdown_power_rating_bpr_a_new_power_metric/?utm_source=amp&utm_medium=&utm_content=post_body
Analytics
• Should be flexible and adjust weighting, i.e. if we decide during game-play that one feature or capability is more desirable than we thought
• Should give us ranking list so that human can see and pick a team even if lower on list
Sites and Apps
• FRC Tracker https://frctracker.com/
more here ... review and note the good and the bad --> Scouting Notes